Your cart is empty
Browse MushroomsHand harvested gourmet Blue Oyster mushrooms grown in small batches right here in New Holland, Ohio. Fresh from our fruiting tent to your kitchen.
Our Story
Every block at Simpson's Spores gets hand inoculated and tended from start to finish. I dial in the temperature, humidity, and airflow throughout the whole process to grow dense, flavorful Blue Oysters. No mass production. No shortcuts.
Precise fruiting chamber conditions for optimal growth
Premium hardwood-based substrate, pasteurized in-house
Small batches grown right here in New Holland, Ohio
Restaurant-quality mushrooms available direct to you
Our Products
Pleurotus ostreatus var. columbinus
Hand harvested gourmet Blue Oysters with a meaty texture and rich umami flavor. Great in stir fries, pasta, soups, or just sautéed in butter and garlic. Way better than what you'll find at the grocery store.
📍 Local pickup only in central Ohio
Coming Soon
Grow your own Blue Oyster mushrooms at home. Our colonized substrate blocks are coming soon. Just cut, mist, and harvest your own gourmet mushrooms. Follow us on social media to be the first to know when they drop.
🌱 Coming soon. Sign up for updates
Why Blue Oyster?
Blue Oyster mushrooms pack serious nutrition alongside great taste. Here's why they're worth adding to your diet.
A plant-based protein source perfect for health-conscious eaters and anyone looking to add nutritious whole foods to their diet.
Rich in beta-glucans and antioxidants that support a healthy immune system and overall well-being.
Low in calories, high in fiber, and a good source of essential B vitamins. A nutritious addition to any heart healthy diet.
Sauté in butter and garlic, throw them in a stir fry, or simmer in a soup. Their meaty texture holds up in just about any dish.
Mushrooms are one of the most eco friendly foods you can grow. Minimal water, small footprint, and they thrive on renewable substrates.
Harvested right before pickup so you get mushrooms at their absolute best. Firm, fragrant, and full of flavor.
How It Works
Reach out through our contact page or social media to reserve your mushrooms and pick your size.
Your mushrooms are hand harvested from our fruiting chamber the day of pickup for maximum freshness.
Pickup in New Holland with meetups available in Circleville, Lancaster, Columbus, and surrounding areas.
Reviews
We're a new farm and would love to hear from our first customers. Your honest feedback helps us grow and helps others discover Simpson's Spores.
Leave a ReviewFresh Blue Oyster mushrooms available now for local pickup in New Holland and central Ohio. Small batch and hand harvested.
Order Now
